Lord You I Love with All My Heart

Lord, You I love with all my heart

Lord You I Love with All My Heart is a hymn text by Martin Schalling (1567) in 8.7.8.7.8.8.7 meter. Translated by Catherine Winkworth. Found in CW21 817, CW93 434, ELH 406, elw 816. Sung to HERZLICH TUT MICH.

This hymn expresses the central Lutheran understanding of justification through faith, emphasizing the believer's loving response to Christ's redemptive work. It exemplifies the devotional character of Lutheran hymnody, combining doctrinal precision with warm affective piety.

History & Background

Martin Behm wrote this German hymn in the early 17th century as a personal confession of faith and love for Christ. Catherine Winkworth translated it into English in 1858, making it widely available to English-speaking Lutheran congregations.

Hymnal Appearances

  • Christian Worship: Hymnal — 817
  • Christian Worship — 434
  • Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary — 406
  • Evangelical Lutheran Worship — 816
  • Lutheran Book of Worship — 325
  • Lutheran Service Book — 708
  • Lutheran Worship — 413
  • Trinity Hymnal — 729
  • The Lutheran Hymnal — 429
  • Voices Together — 614
  • With One Voice — 697

Translation

Catherine Winkworth

Bulletin Note

Martin Behm (1610) wrote this hymn in the Reformation tradition, balancing rigorous doctrinal precision about justification with warm, personal devotion. The tune HERZLICH TUT MICH perfectly captures its affective power.

Preaching Connection

This hymn crystallizes the movement from Law to Gospel: the summons to love God completely gives way to the comfort of Christ's forgiveness and the Spirit's sustaining grace in our struggle against sin.

Stanza Arc

The narrative or theological arc traced by this tune's stanzas: Law to Gospel: from the demand to love God completely (St. 1) through confession of sin and need for Christ's redemption (St. 2), to the Holy Spirit's sustaining comfort (St. 3), culminating in trinitarian confidence and eschatological hope (St. 4)

Original & Other Translations

Original (German): Herzlich lieb hab ich dich, o Herr

English versions recorded by Julian (1907), by first line, oldest first:

  • 1725 “Thee, Lord, I love with sacred awe” — J. C. Jacobi
  • 1845 “I love Thee, Lord, with love sincere” — H. Mills
  • 1851 “My heart, O Lord, its love on Thee” — Arthur T. Russell
  • 1857 “With all my heart I love Thee, Lord” — H. G. de Bunsen
  • 1858 “Lord, all my heart is fixed on Thee” — Catherine Winkworth
  • 1869 “O Lord! I love Thee from my heart” — Schaff's Christ in Song (translator not named)
Show 1 more
  • 1877 “Lord, Thee I love with all my heart” — Richard Massie

Source: John Julian, A Dictionary of Hymnology (2nd ed., London, 1907) .

In the Church Year

Hymn of the Day (Lutheran Service Book) for: Lent 2; Trinity 19; Proper 21

Suggested in the one-year series

  • Trinity 19 (6×)
  • Trinity 1 (7×)
  • Trinity 13 (3×)
  • Trinity 7 (2×)
  • Pentecost Monday (1×)
  • St. Michael and All Angels (1×)

Suggested in the three-year series

  • Lent 2 (8×)
  • Proper 21 (3×)
  • Easter 7 (3×)
  • Proper 10 (2×)
  • Lent 5 (1×)
  • Proper 17 (1×)
  • Proper 25 (1×)
  • Proper 26 (1×)

From LCMS Worship's published hymn suggestions, 2014–2026. The count is how many of those yearly lists suggested this hymn for that day.

AI-assisted draft These study notes were drafted with AI from the hymn text and have not yet been reviewed line by line. Treat them as a starting point and check them against the sources.

Overview

Martin Schalling, a Lutheran pastor who suffered for refusing to sign a Calvinizing confession, wrote this as a prayer based on Psalms 18 and 73. Its three long stanzas correspond to the three articles of the Creed: love for Christ above heaven and earth, bought by his blood (st. 1); gratitude for body and soul, with prayer to serve the neighbor and bear the cross (st. 2); and a prayer for a blessed death, peaceful rest, and resurrection (st. 3). Bach used st. 3 as the closing chorale of the St. John Passion.

Central theme: Wholehearted love and trust in Christ through life, vocation, death, and resurrection

Structure

Three long stanzas: love and redemption (1); creation, vocation, cross (2); death, sleep, resurrection (3). Each ends with 'Lord Jesus Christ' and a short petition.

Law & Gospel Shape

Gospel throughout; sorrow, false doctrine, Satan, and death are named and met by Christ.

Confessional Connections

Christ's blood as the price of redemption (Second Article); creation and vocation (First Article; 'serve and help my neighbor'); death as sleep and the resurrection of the body (AC XVII). Concern for pure doctrine reflects Schalling's own confessional struggle.

Liturgical Use (Study Notes)

Funerals (especially st. 3); Trinity season; confirmation; vocations Sunday; personal devotion.

Historical Notes

Schalling (1532-1608), pastor in Amberg and later Nuremberg, was deposed for refusing a Calvinist confession and later for hesitating over the Formula of Concord. The hymn was published in 1571.

About the Tune

HERZLICH LIEB (Bernhard Schmid's Orgeltabulatur-Buch, 1577) — long, expansive melody.

Scripture References

Ps 18:1-2 Ps 73:25-26 1 Pet 1:18-19 Gal 5:13 Matt 16:24 Luke 16:22 1 Thess 4:13-14 Job 19:25-27 1 Cor 15:51-52

Stanza by Stanza

1 Lord, Thee I love with all my heart…

Lord, I love you with my whole heart; never leave me, but cheer me with your mercies; earth has nothing I want, and heaven would be empty without you; if my heart breaks with sorrow, no one can shake my trust; you are my portion, your blood bought my soul; Lord Jesus Christ, do not forsake me — I trust your Word.

Ps 18:1 ('I love you, O LORD, my strength') and Ps 73:25-26 ('Whom have I in heaven but you? And there is nothing on earth that I desire besides you… God is the strength of my heart and my portion forever'). The striking line 'heaven itself were void and bare / If Thou, Lord, wert not near me' says that heaven is heaven because of Christ, not merely because of its pleasures. 'Thy precious blood my soul has bought' (1 Pet 1:18-19) grounds the love: it answers being bought. The closing 'I trust Thy Word' — the believer's confidence in sorrow rests on the external promise.

Scripture
Ps 18:1-2, Ps 73:25-26, 1 Pet 1:18-19, 1 John 4:19, Ps 16:5
Imagery & language
Portion; heart breaking; blood as price.
Law / Gospel
Gospel — love answering redemption.
Connection to previous
Love and redemption (Second Article).
love for Christ redemption trust in the Word Christ as portion
2 Yea, Lord, 'twas Thy rich bounty gave…

Lord, your generosity gave me body, soul, and everything in this life of work; may I glorify your grace everywhere and serve and help my neighbor; keep false doctrine and Satan from my soul; give strength and patience to bear my cross and follow you; Lord Jesus Christ, comfort me in death.

A First Article stanza almost in the words of Luther's Small Catechism ('God has given me my body and soul… all that I need'). The response to gifts is twofold: glorify God's grace and 'serve and help my neighbor' — Luther's teaching that good works are directed to the neighbor in one's vocation (Gal 5:13). 'Let no false doctrine me beguile' reflects Schalling's experience (2 Tim 4:3-4). Cross-bearing (Matt 16:24) is not chosen but given and borne with strength and patience from God. The stanza ends already looking toward death.

Scripture
Acts 17:25, Jas 1:17, Gal 5:13, 1 Pet 4:10, 2 Tim 4:3-4, Matt 16:24, Col 1:11
Imagery & language
Bounty; labor; cross.
Law / Gospel
Gospel (gifts) and new obedience (service, cross-bearing).
Connection to previous
Gifts and vocation (First Article).
creation vocation love of neighbor pure doctrine cross-bearing
3 Lord, let at last Thine angels come…

Lord, at the end send your angels to carry me to Abraham's bosom so I may die without fear; keep my body safe in the grave in peaceful sleep until your return; then wake me from death so my own eyes may see with joy your glorious face, Son of God, my Savior and fountain of grace; Lord Jesus Christ, hear my prayer, and I will praise you forever.

The great deathbed stanza, set by Bach as the final chorale of the St. John Passion. 'Thine angels… To Abram's bosom bear me home' — Luke 16:22, Lazarus carried by angels. 'Narrow chamber' — the grave as a bedroom where the body 'sleeps' (1 Thess 4:13-14; Isa 26:19-20). 'Until Thy reappearing… from death awaken me' — bodily resurrection on the Last Day (1 Cor 15:51-52). 'These mine eyes… may see' quotes Job 19:26-27 ('in my flesh I shall see God… my eyes shall behold'). Lutheran eschatology in miniature: the soul with Christ, the body resting, both reunited at the resurrection.

Scripture
Luke 16:22, 1 Thess 4:13-14, Isa 26:19-20, 1 Cor 15:51-52, Job 19:25-27, 1 John 3:2
Imagery & language
Angels; Abraham's bosom; narrow chamber; awakening; seeing the face.
Law / Gospel
Gospel — blessed death and resurrection.
Connection to previous
Death and resurrection (Third Article).
death resurrection of the body beatific vision angels

Themes

Love for Christ Confession of faith Trust in God's mercy Devotion and commitment Love of God Personal devotion Repentance and faith Joy in salvation

Related Hymns

Look Further