Lord Tis Not that I did Choose You

Lord, 'tis not that I did choose Thee

Lord Tis Not that I did Choose You is a hymn text by Josiah Conder (1824) in 8.8.8.8 meter. Found in CW21 581, CW93 380, ELH 222, elw 701. Sung to JESUS LOVES ME.

The hymn expresses the Lutheran doctrine of justification by grace alone, emphasizing that salvation originates entirely from God's sovereign choice rather than human merit or decision. It affirms the Reformation principle of monergistic grace while presenting the comfort and assurance found in Christ's electing love.

History & Background

Written by Josiah Conder, a Congregationalist minister and hymn writer, and first published in 1824. The text has been widely adopted in Lutheran hymnals and reflects Reformed theology of divine election.

Hymnal Appearances

  • Christian Worship: Hymnal β€” 581
  • Christian Worship β€” 380
  • Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary β€” 222
  • Evangelical Lutheran Worship β€” 701
  • Lutheran Service Book β€” 573
  • The Lutheran Hymnal β€” 37

Bulletin Note

Josiah Conder (1824) captures Reformation truth: salvation springs from God's sovereign election, not human decision. The hymn's simplicity and directness have made it a cherished voice of Lutheran assurance across centuries.

Preaching Connection

This hymn crystallizes the Gospel's response to human helplessness: when the Law exposes our inability to choose God rightly, the Gospel announces that God has already chosen us—a comfort that amplifies the joy of justification by grace alone.

Catechism & Confessional Connections

Stanza Arc

The narrative or theological arc traced by this tune's stanzas: Law-Gospel movement: human righteousness exposed as insufficient (stanzas 1-2), Christ's alien righteousness imputed and clothing the believer (stanzas 3-4), concluding in faith-alone boasting

In the Church Year

Suggested in the one-year series

  • Septuagesima (1Γ—)
  • St. Luke (1Γ—)

Suggested in the three-year series

  • Proper 13 (1Γ—)

From LCMS Worship's published hymn suggestions, 2014–2026. The count is how many of those yearly lists suggested this hymn for that day.

AI-assisted draft These study notes were drafted with AI from the hymn text and have not yet been reviewed line by line. Treat them as a starting point and check them against the sources.

Overview

Josiah Conder, an English Congregationalist editor and hymn writer, wrote this hymn on John 15:16: 'You did not choose me, but I chose you.' It confesses that the heart would still refuse God if grace had not chosen it first, and that grace washed and ordained it to live for God (st. 1); that grace in Christ called and enlightened a darkened mind, and that our love is only the answer to his prior love (st. 2); and it closes in praise of the Triune God (st. 3). It is a concise hymn of salvation by grace alone — monergism in verse.

Central theme: Salvation is wholly God's choosing and calling in Christ; our love for him is the fruit of his love for us

Structure

Three eight-line stanzas (8.7.8.7 D). God's choice (1) — God's call (2) — Trinitarian praise (3).

Law & Gospel Shape

Law: 'this heart would still refuse Thee'; 'my darkened heart and mind'; 'the world had yet enthralled me' (1-2). Gospel: 'Thy grace… chosen me'; 'washed and cleansed'; 'Thou… didst love me first' (1-2).

Confessional Connections

FC II (Free Will): by nature 'man's heart… is hostile to God' and cannot accept grace by its own powers; conversion is wholly the Spirit's work through the Word. FC XI (Election): God's eternal election in Christ is a cause of our salvation and a comfort; it is not to be investigated apart from Christ and the Gospel. Conder was a Calvinist, but this text affirms nothing Lutherans reject — it confesses election to salvation and is silent about any decree of reprobation (FC XI.5-6, 81-84). 'He first loved us' (1 John 4:19; AC XX on good works as fruits).

Liturgical Use (Study Notes)

Trinity season; Holy Baptism; confirmation; Reformation; general.

Historical Notes

Conder (1789-1855) edited The Congregational Hymn Book (1836).

About the Tune

O DU LIEBE MEINER LIEBE (Musikalischer Christenschatz, Basel, 1745).

Scripture References

John 15:16 Eph 1:4-5 Rom 8:7 1 Cor 2:14 Titus 3:5 1 Cor 6:11 Eph 2:10 2 Cor 5:15 2 Tim 1:9 Gal 1:15 2 Cor 4:4-6 Eph 2:1-5 Ps 73:25 1 John 4:10, 19 John 1:29 Heb 7:25-26 Rom 8:11

Stanza by Stanza

1 Lord, 'tis not that I did choose Thee;…

Lord, it is not that I chose you — I know that could never happen, for this heart would still refuse you if your grace had not chosen me. You have washed and cleansed me from the sin that stained me and set me free, and ordained me for this purpose: that I may always live for you.

John 15:16 (TLH's text): 'You did not choose me, but I chose you and appointed you.' The natural heart 'would still refuse' (Rom 8:7; 1 Cor 2:14; FC II.7). Washed and cleansed (Titus 3:5; 1 Cor 6:11 — Baptism). 'Ordained… that I ever live to Thee' — new life is the goal of election (Eph 2:10; 2 Cor 5:15).

Scripture
John 15:16, Rom 8:7, 1 Cor 2:14, Titus 3:5, 1 Cor 6:11, Eph 2:10, 2 Cor 5:15
Imagery & language
Choosing; washing; ordaining.
Law / Gospel
Law — the refusing heart; Gospel — grace chooses and cleanses.
Connection to previous
Chosen.
election bondage of the will Baptism
2 'Twas Thy grace in Christ that called me,…

It was your grace in Christ that called me and taught my darkened heart and mind; otherwise the world would still have held me captive, blind to your heavenly glories. Now my heart acknowledges no one above you; I thirst for your grace alone, knowing well that if I love you, you, Lord, loved me first.

'In Christ' — election is never apart from Christ (Eph 1:4; FC XI.65-66). The call through the Gospel (2 Tim 1:9; SC Third Article: 'the Holy Spirit has called me by the Gospel'). Darkened minds enlightened (2 Cor 4:4-6). 'We love because he first loved us' (1 John 4:19).

Scripture
Eph 1:4, 2 Tim 1:9, 2 Cor 4:4-6, Eph 2:1-5, Ps 73:25, 1 John 4:10, 19
Imagery & language
Calling; darkness; first love.
Law / Gospel
Gospel — grace calls; his love first.
Connection to previous
Called.
calling conversion love of God
3 Praise the God of all creation;…

Praise the God of all creation; praise the Father's boundless love. Praise the Lamb, our atonement, Priest and King enthroned above. Praise the Spirit of salvation, by whom our spirits live. Give undivided worship to the great Jehovah.

A Trinitarian doxology mirroring the Creed's three articles. 'The Lamb, our Expiation' (John 1:29; 1 John 2:2). 'Priest and King' (Heb 7:25-26; Rev 5:6). The Spirit gives life (Rom 8:11; John 6:63). 'Undivided adoration' — one God (Deut 6:4).

Scripture
John 1:29, 1 John 2:2, Heb 7:25-26, Rom 8:11, Deut 6:4
Imagery & language
Lamb; Priest and King; Spirit.
Law / Gospel
Gospel — praise.
Connection to previous
Doxology.
Trinity atonement doxology

Themes

Election and predestination God's initiative in salvation Justification by grace Union with Christ Divine election and grace Predestination The believer's assurance God's sovereign choice Christian perseverance

Related Hymns

Look Further