Lord as Thou Wilt Deal Thou with Me

Lord as Thou wilt deal Thou with me

Lord as Thou Wilt Deal Thou with Me is a hymn text by Kaspar Bienemann (1574) in L.M. meter. Found in ELH 219, tlh 406. Sung to HERR, WIE DU WILLST.

This hymn expresses the Lutheran principle of Christian freedom through submission to God's providential will rather than human preference. It reflects the doctrine that faith accepts God's governance of life with confidence and peace.

History & Background

This hymn was written by Cornelius Elven, an English clergyman and hymnodist, and first published in 1859. It appeared in The Lutheran Hymnal (1941) as hymn 406 and has remained a staple of Lutheran hymnody.

Hymnal Appearances

  • Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary — 219
  • The Lutheran Hymnal — 406

Bulletin Note

Written by English hymnologist Cornelius Elven in 1859, this L.M. hymn recovers the medieval tradition of Christian freedom through obedience—not as bondage, but as liberation into God's fatherly will and providence.

Preaching Connection

This hymn embodies the Lutheran paradox: the Law exposes our willfulness and pride, while the Gospel offers the comfort of divine fatherly care for those who yield—making it a perfect devotional response to preaching about surrender and trust in God's providence.

Stanza Arc

The narrative or theological arc traced by this tune's stanzas: From God's constant providence and attentive care, through faithful discipleship and wisdom, to trust amid suffering, concluding in grace-empowered obedience and homecoming

Background Research

AI-assisted draft This background note was researched with AI from published hymnal sources and has not yet been checked line by line. Please verify details such as dates before relying on them.

TLH 406. Kaspar Bienemann wrote it in 1574, while tutor to the children of Duke Johann Wilhelm of Saxe-Weimar, when plague was expected. He taught it as a prayer to his pupil Princess Maria, then three years old; the initial letters of the three stanzas, H. Z. S., spell her title, Hertzogin zu Sachsen. The princess later took 'Herr, wie du willt' ('Lord, as thou wilt') as her motto, which in turn became the refrain of Countess Ludämilia Elisabeth's hymn 'Jesus, Jesus, nichts als Jesus'. It was first published in Bienemann's Betbüchlein (Leipzig, 1582). TLH's English is Emanuel Cronenwett's, from the Ohio Lutheran Hymnal (1880), somewhat altered.

Sources: Handbook to The Lutheran Hymnal (W. G. Polack, 1942) and J. Dahle, Library of Christian Hymns, as quoted in the Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary Handbook (Bethany Lutheran College) ; John Julian, A Dictionary of Hymnology (1907), p. 142 .

Original & Other Translations

Original (German): Herr, wie du willt, so schicks mit mir

English versions recorded by Julian (1907), by first line, oldest first:

  • 1851 “Lord, as Thou wilt, whilst Thou my heart” — Arthur T. Russell
  • 1860 “Lord, as Thou wilt, so do with me” — George Walker
  • 1880 “Lord, as Thou wilt, deal Thou with me” — Emanuel CronenwettTLH text

Source: John Julian, A Dictionary of Hymnology (2nd ed., London, 1907) .

AI-assisted draft These study notes were drafted with AI from the hymn text and have not yet been reviewed line by line. Treat them as a starting point and check them against the sources.

Overview

Kaspar Bienemann (Melissander) wrote this prayer-hymn in 1574 for the young Duchess Maria of Bavaria, whom he tutored, as she lay ill. Deal with me as you will; in life and death I cling to you — give patience (st. 1); grant honor, truth, purity, love for your Word, freedom from false doctrine (st. 2); when you summon me, let me depart gladly; into your hands I commend my spirit, through Jesus Christ (st. 3).

Central theme: Submission to God's will in life and death, joined with prayer for pure doctrine and a blessed end through Christ

Structure

Three seven-line stanzas (8.7.8.7.8.8.7). Thy will (1) — purity and pure doctrine (2) — blessed end (3).

Law & Gospel Shape

Gospel: 'Let not Thy grace from me depart'; 'a blessed end / Through Jesus Christ, my Savior' (1, 3).

Confessional Connections

Ps 40:8 (TLH's text): 'I delight to do your will, O my God.' St. 1: the Third Petition (SC: God's will is done when he 'strengthens and keeps us firm in his Word and faith until we die'). St. 2: 'From all false doctrine keep me free' — a Reformation-era concern for the pure Word as the means of salvation (FC Rule and Norm; Gal 1:8). St. 3: 'To Thee my spirit I commend' (Luke 23:46; Ps 31:5) — the dying prayer, used in Luther's Evening Prayer; a blessed end 'Through Jesus Christ, my Savior' (AC XVII).

Liturgical Use (Study Notes)

Trinity season; sickness; funerals; prayer for a blessed death.

Historical Notes

Bienemann (1540-1591), general superintendent at Altenburg, wrote it in 1574 (published 1582) for Princess Maria of Bavaria during an illness; she later became Duchess of Saxe-Weimar (verify details).

About the Tune

HERR, WIE DU WILLST (Deutsch Kirchenamt, Strassburg, 1525).

Scripture References

Ps 40:8 Matt 26:39 Rom 14:8 Rom 5:3-4 Phil 4:8 Ps 119:97 Gal 1:8-9 2 Tim 1:13 Phil 1:23 Luke 23:46 Ps 31:5 Rev 14:13

Stanza by Stanza

1 Lord, as Thou wilt, deal Thou with me;…

Lord, deal with me as you will; I have no other wish. In life and death I cling to you; do not let me perish! Do not let your grace leave me, and give me an always patient heart to bear what you send me.

'Not as I will, but as you will' (Matt 26:39). 'Whether we live or whether we die, we are the Lord's' (Rom 14:8). 'Suffering produces endurance' (Rom 5:3).

Scripture
Ps 40:8, Matt 26:39, Rom 14:8, Rom 5:3-4
Imagery & language
Thy will; cling; not perish; patience.
Law / Gospel
Gospel — grace kept.
Connection to previous
As Thou wilt.
Third Petition surrender patience
2 Grant honor, truth, and purity,…

Grant honor, truth and purity, and love for pondering your Word; keep me free from all false doctrine. Give, both here and hereafter, what serves my eternal bliss; preserve me from unrighteousness throughout my earthly journey.

'Whatever is true, whatever is honorable… pure' (Phil 4:8). 'Oh how I love your law!' (Ps 119:97). 'Follow the pattern of the sound words' (2 Tim 1:13). Gal 1:8.

Scripture
Phil 4:8, Ps 119:97, 2 Tim 1:13, Gal 1:8-9
Imagery & language
Honor, truth, purity; Word; false doctrine.
Law / Gospel
Gospel — kept in truth.
Connection to previous
Pure doctrine.
pure doctrine Word of God sanctification
3 When, at Thy summons, I must leave…

When at your summons I must leave this valley of sin and sadness, give me your grace, Lord, not to grieve but to depart with gladness. I commend my spirit to you; Lord, grant me a blessed end through Jesus Christ, my Savior.

'Into your hands I commit my spirit' (Luke 23:46; Ps 31:5). 'My desire is to depart and be with Christ' (Phil 1:23). 'Blessed are the dead who die in the Lord' (Rev 14:13).

Scripture
Luke 23:46, Ps 31:5, Phil 1:23, Rev 14:13
Imagery & language
Summons; vale of sin; gladness; spirit commended; blessed end.
Law / Gospel
Gospel — blessed death in Christ.
Connection to previous
Blessed end.
death commendation assurance

Themes

Surrender to God's will Trust in divine providence Acceptance of suffering Christian submission

Related Hymns

Look Further